why did alice lie about her name in closer

Leia Mais . Enter Closer, a movie about fucking the lying men for lies. Answer: Yes there is a connection, but the exact meaning of it is deliberately left ambiguous as to why Alice/Jane kept her true identity hidden. Can patents be featured/explained in a youtube video i.e. Rename .gz files according to names in separate txt-file. Even pairs Anna/Alice and Larry/Dan who are not romantically involved with each other and meet to talk only once (if we exclude the net conversation) influence each others lives strongly. My name is Jane. All the reasons above saying she didnt rely on the love between Dan and Alice (untrue). I think that Anna didn't know what she wanted. What is the meaning of the title "Closer"? You can unsubscribe at any time. Vic Tayback reprised his role from the movie. Answer: She chose the first name she remembered when Dan asks her name. He approaches Anna at the Aquarium because he thinks she is the person who wanted to meet with him for casual sex. The other times were guilted facades of who she really was. The last scene in the film is delusively similar to the one opening it. I'm supposed to leave you. Question: I don't understand the scene where Alice and Dan break up at the end, and why Alice says that she "would have" loved Dan forever. She was the only one who did the right thing. So Tim Burton's Alice takes place during her 2nd visit in Wonderland. Last she doesn't focus the lens when she takes a picture. In the play, upon which the film is based, however, there is a scene at a museum, in which Larry And Alice act as a couple, with Larry telling Anna about the fact that he and Alice are having sex. It's because she doesn't need me. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". Did Alice really sleep with Larry in Closer? Question: Before Dan and Alice left for Anna's show, why didn't Dan want Alice to travel with him after the show? Why does Alice lie about her name in Closer. Does Alice die at the end of closer? The end, contrary to the beginning, does not leave much hope for anyone. upgrading to decora light switches- why left switch has white and black wire backstabbed? Chronological Plot Summary. To win Anna back he had to manipulate all the players including Alice/ Jane. Some more months later, Daniel and Alice will be at Annas photographic exhibition, and Daniel will convince Anna to become his secret lover.if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[580,400],'auralcrave_com-large-leaderboard-2','ezslot_8',109,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-auralcrave_com-large-leaderboard-2-0'); The affair between Daniel and Anna goes on for one year, then one night, simultaneously, Daniel confesses to Alice hes in love with Anna, and Anna reveals to Larry shes been seeing Dan for months. Closer is a movie released in 2004, directed by Mike Nichols. Presumably Alice has been through difficult situations: abuse, neglect, etc. There's the first plot twist of this whole saga - while the pair grew up together on the Southside, Alice was a Serpent before FP ever was. All rights reserved. A. Alice awakes in the hospital and recognizes that everything she once knew had changed. Dan ends up alone, Anna is back with Larry but none of them seem happy, they are just another marriage bored with each other, Larry sleeping in the marital bed, Anna at the other end of it, the longing in her eyes suggesting she is not enjoying the here and now. He makes a shocking discovery: he finds a tile with the name Alice Ayers written on it. To provide for free national day care. Anna meets Larry, the two start dating and will eventually get married. It also heightens the ever-permeating impression of the distance between the people in the movie. Although it speaks closer, there is hardly any intimacy between the characters. A white rabbit What did the Rabbit take out of his waistcoat? Living in London, England, where she meets Dan Woolf by chance after getting hit by a car. Answer: Every time she had pink hair, like in the beginning of the film and during her club scene, she was her true self. Why did Alice tell herself to stop crying? She considers herself a "nobody" and enjoys lying as a form of control. How to react to a students panic attack in an oral exam? Question: After leaving Larry for Dan, why did Anna break up with him and reunite with Larry? Revealing the falsity and transience of human relations in modern world, an anti-love story is an equally suitable name for Closer. Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors. 8 Why did Ally get in trouble for the card she gave to Mrs. Hall before she left on maternity leave? All the prints show the full negative and the outside area of the negative. Finally, at their first meeting, during their cybersex with Larry, Dan, pretending to be Anna, writes (s)he fantasizes about strangers. A few weeks later, a devastated Daniel visits Larry at his studio and asks him to leave Anna. He was a little boy. Confira isto | at quantos anos homem cresce. Dan only wanted to know how Larry was better than him. Their names - Ina, Alice and Edith - are almost legend, the golden afternoon on the river that gave rise to the story immortalised in Dodgson's own verse. Portman knew that she loved Jude Laws character, and because of this she always had to have some kind of advantage over him. Dan (M, 25-40) Alice and Dan meet at the start of the play. Clue 3: When Dan was nagging her about why she slept with Larry, she replied that she desired him and he asked nicely. Carroll would tell stories about strange adventures underground to entertain Alice and her other sisters as innocent fun on warm summer days. The film is set in London. Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. The title refers to the central theme of the film and the play upon which it is based: 7 biggest mistakes in Star Wars: Episode VII - The Force Awakens, The 20 biggest mistakes in The Wizard of Oz, 40 biggest mistakes in The Big Bang Theory, 6 Cool things you've never noticed in movies, The biggest mistakes in the Harry Potter movies, 25 mistakes you never noticed in great movies, 7 mistakes in Beetlejuice you never spotted. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc. As an audience member, I believe Alice and Larry did not have sex. She is only shown stripping in front of him. As a viewer, I would like to believe your version though. The fact that he was willing to give her freedom, is what made her choose him. Why does Alice lie about her name in closer? How old was Natalie Portman when filming Closer? At the film's conclusion, Alice returns to the United States and Dan returns to the very place . Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. The trials that followed ensured we'd never know who murdered themonly that a woman's life could be used against her. Click the card to flip . Profession former stripper. Notice how he questioned her about her appearance - she claimed to have had a bath, but was dressed again. Alice did not sleep with Larry. This time she knew she just wouldn't be. Answer: This is not an official answer, but my interpretation is that them both being American makes them interchangeable, in a way. Dan Anna and Larry are the children and they acted childish. Anna needs him to sign the divorce papers, and he has an indecent proposal: he will sign the documents if she has sex with him one last time. Why did Alice lie about her name in closer? The title refers to the central theme of the film and the play upon which it is based: Knowing the truth doesn't bring us closer together. I think he set her up because he wanted to prank her for rejecting him. Alice did not sleep with Larry. Larry did in fact sleep with Alice this in the movie is portrayed when Dan is leaving Larry's office. It just felt like time, mostly for me as an artist, time for me to do something else. She wants to leave him before he can possibly change his mind and leave her. Yet she was a liar (who was hiding her identity to Dan) and a stripper (who was getting paid providing sexual fantasies). She seems to enjoy this work and the anonymity it providesconstantly being able to change her name and not having to answer any real questions. Alices name is there and it says Alice gave her life to save 3 children from a burning house. By telling everyone this it was known as a fact. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance". Could very old employee stock options still be accessible and viable? Just like Alice slept with him and so did Anna stayed with him. Dan only wanted to know how Larry was better than him. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. Larry: Your real name. Question: *spoilers* I read that in the play, Alice is hit by a car and killed. Alice Crimmins, right, waits in line with the crowd before a session of her 1971 trial. Dan is an unachieved writer who works in the Siberia of journalism writing obituaries. Answer: Before Anna's show, they were not arguing about Dan and Alice leaving the show together - they were arguing because Dan was travelling straight after the show and staying somewhere else overnight to be at his father's funeral. That she is the one that is supposed to break it off with him. Every time she had pink hair, like in the beginning of the film and during her club scene, she was her true self. The images on Auralcrave or similar could be downloaded and edited ondepositphotos.com. In the film, it is heavily insinuated that they did have sex. Embarrassing Cover-Up. She still loved Dan. She tells Bob that she's having that time of the month. How did the cast get along? A logical explanation to her shock is she was lying about the sex and did not know Larry lied too. I couldn't figure out why all the other pedestrians are looking at her, before she gets to the crosswalk. Alice : Oh, as if you had no choice? When they met, Alice had pink-reddish hair and lied about her name, after having seen the name in one of the tombstones at the cemetery. Pola, ktrych wypenienie jest wymagane, s oznaczone symbolem. What they are scared of is emotional pain. Every emotion experienced by a character finds its reflection in the portrayal created by the actor, especially in case of Natalie Portman whose face seems to be able of expressing any feeling from genuine sadness to naughty cheekiness in the course of one shot. Just an unlucky fluke for the second part with them meeting up at the same time, I think. In the movie Closer, everybody needs love and sex, but their actions are often not coherent enough to keep their relationships. What happened to Alice at the end of Closer? She still loved Dan. Over four years, their lives intertwine in many ways. Larry and Alice even have some brief encounters, the characters always wanting the partners they dont have. PTIJ Should we be afraid of Artificial Intelligence? He . Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. But then you realize she loves Arima instead. EL3 .D645a 866b. Or did it just happen because of Larry's confession? Portman knew that she loved Jude Law's character, and because of this she always had to have some kind of advantage over him. Answer: It's left for your interpretation. Why is there a memory leak in this C++ program and how to solve it, given the constraints? Alice wanted to go to the funeral with him but Dan said he wanted to be alone. Everybody knew. Question 18: Write True or False: (a) "I don't see any wine," Alice remarked - True. The viewer remembers Larrys words everything is a version of something else. She did love the way he treated her. He promised that if they had sex one more time, he would leave her alone and never contact her again. Auralcrave is a registered trademark. Larry: Alice, tell me something true.Alice: Lying's the most fun a girl can have without taking her clothes off - but it's better if you do. This was the scene at the theater/opera, whatever it was. More that he was just going to different clubs and drinking and came across the club, I think he knew exactly where to find her. Dan did not love Alice. A possible parallel is that she sensed a chance to "save", She chose the first name she remembered when. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. Or was it just a coincidence with the choice of actresses? Alice is the main protagonist from Disney's 1951 film Alice in Wonderland and the book that the film was adapted from. Weird people tend to congregate in Mondstadt. I think he wanted to gain control of his relationship with. She initially denies it but a short while later, she says she doesnt love him anymore and that she did sleep with Larry. At the ending of the movie Dan is walking in the park where his dad took him and he finds himself with the names of people that gave their lives to save other people. Those left head to the Umbrella base and the now-infected Carlos briefly kisses Alice before driving an oil truck loaded with dynamite into a horde of zombies to clear the way. Over time, her encounter with Larry might have bothered him more and more. Dan says the police in New York called to tell him "Jane Jones" had died, and he learns that was Alice's real name. Question: I know this movie was based on a Broadway play. Answer: It appears so. He was low key stalking all of them, to get Anna back. (tips her) Alice: Thank you. And she lies about herself because she wants the control. Alice remains dedicated to Dan, even as he attempts to woo Anna. It does not store any personal data. I don't believe so because when Dan reveals to her that "he knew" she slept with Larry (because Larry told him) and he just "wanted to hear it from her" (insecure, petty, threatened by Larry always), all this after she admits to him that "yes" she did sleep with Larry, it's clear to me that: her admission was so devoid of spirit, very evident that it's been a well-calculated decision to admit this lie for her own hidden purposes (getting rid of an insecure Dan she can no longer respect etc), a choice she contemplated while he was out buying cigarettes and she decided she cannot love him anymore for her own reasons. By Sarah Weinman. Alice did not sleep with Larry. People expecting a love story in its traditional sense may feel disappointed or even outraged. When Anna confesses she had an affair with Dan, Larry wants to know the details of their sex life. Therefore, he understands that Alice gave him a fictitious name and maintained it over the four years of their relationship. It makes Alice the only one among the four who did not betray their lover (Anna and Dan slept together, Larry slept with a whore in New York). Closer movie quiz. The two get connected and will have sex that night, then Larry returns to London. Mike Nichols Closer is a movie about four people who richly deserve one another. Whether, I think he had played the Internet prank/joke a few times before. Larry notes how she made up everything about herself. For the strip club scene, she agreed to let the film roll while she bared herself, but later decided against using the two-second shot of her closing her top. He insulted her, he humiliated her and yet, in the end, she went back to him of her own free will. What does Lo Debar represent in the Bible? He knew that Anna liked the aquarium, so if he chatted with multiple men on different days, there was a chance that Anna would actually be at the aquarium when a man arrived to meet her. They later reunited for 2004s Closer. All of the places are modern, full of anonymity of a big city. I can't see it, I can't touch it. Anna is a quietly independent divorce and successful photographer. She also says "I'm the one who leaves." As it stands, this makes no sense. Honestly I don't think they had sex. She took the name 'Alice Ayres' from a memorial to a young woman who died saving children from a fire, but reveals her name to Larry, who doesn't believe her. I can hear some words, but I can't do anything with your easy words. Maybe the most honest, trustworthy thing Grace tells Dr. Jordan comes at the end of the series, in the letter she writes him after marrying Jamie Walsh. The papers aim was to analyze particular aspects of the movie and although I am well aware of the numerous interpretations being there somewhere on the net, I decided to share my humble flawed one I chose some of the key points I found least emberrassing and here they are presented below: There is a certain type of perversity in the title of the film itself. She initially denies it but a short while later, she says she doesnt love him anymore and that she did sleep with Larry. Alice is woken up from her sleep she most likely fell into while she was waiting for Dan to come back home, she is dressed in her pyjamas, wearing no make-up with a completely bare face which only heightens her defencelessness. In a moment of truth with Larry, she reveals that she is "Plain Jane", implying that she can only feel special and lovable, and 'in love', when she is playing a role. December 3, 2004 (USA)Closer / Release date. He can be quite cold and controlling. a girl (who most of the movie appears as the least experienced and most ingenuous) and a woman (who was mature enough to realize he was not reliable). Dan sets the betrayals in motion, by cheating on Alice with Anna, who later marries Larry, only to cheat on him by taking up with Dan again. However, despite the fact that I find your analysis quite detailed and thought provoking, it is speculative. Chosen answer: I saw the play some years ago in London, and I seem to remember she gets run over by a car. why does grapefruit taste like soap; nome astratto di vedere; christian taylor police; green circle around snapchat story. Dan has begun asking questions about Larry. What are some examples of how providers can receive incentives? There really wasnt an epiphany. This is how the movie Closer explained its real meaning: yes, Alice has lied to Daniel for years about her name. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. She treated Larry as a customer and did not even let him touch her. Also when she uses the 35mm camera sometimes she advances the film manually and sometimes you hear a motor drive. Who knows. Answer: Dan wrote the address on his prescription pad and passed it to Larry. All the prints show the full negative and the outside area of the negative. Later on, Dan kept asking Alice if she slept with Larry. Alice loves Dan, but right now, she's just putting herself through needless pain. The movie then flashes forward one year. 1988 2021; jmthund valp till salu. Despite her profession, Alice seems to be the most innocent one in the film. This plan ultimately failed when her co-worker, Spence stole the virus samples with the . The anonymity is taken to its extreme in the scene where Dan and Larry have a conversation on the net where Dan impersonates Anna and have virtual sex with Larry. Larry returns tired from a business trip to be greeted by his wife at home, yet what he finds at home is not a warm greeting but the truth hard to bear. Dan insisted on knowing if Anna had sex with Larry, when she met with Larry to discuss the divorce. We then learn that Alices real name was in fact Jane, as she had insisted to Larry, and that she had been lying to Dan throughout their entire relationship. Even more honest when she said I dont love you since now. What was the point of closer? She did not say her real name because she wants to be somebody else, possibly because Jane came from NY to escape a life she had there and wanted to reinvent herself. Larry seems a narcissist and is childish: I think it is a "revenge" for what happened. Is an encumbrance the same as an easement? Suspicious referee report, are "suggested citations" from a paper mill? She preferred keeping some secrets from Dan, never trusting him fully. Does anyone know how it is revealed in the play what Alice's real name is, and also how Dan realizes that "Alice Ayers" was a fake name? In "A View To A Kill" why does Zorin let Bond sleep with May Day? Watch The Closer: The Complete First Season | Prime Video. Wooden blocks her grandfather made. Alice lied to get rid of Dan. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. Question: Is there a significance to Jane choosing Alice Ayer's name? Her identity crisis plays out in the way she constantly reinvents herself by changing her appearance. What is thought to influence the overproduction and pruning of synapses in the brain quizlet? Acting. They soon start a relationship which is over by the end of Act 1 when Dan admits to having an affair with Anna (this is one of the audition pieces). Yet, she tries to built her whole new life in London on a lie (her true name is Jane Jones, Alice Ayres is the name of a woman who died saving kids from a burning building). Rent. The End. Alice leaves England and goes back to America. In that visit, Alice arrives in Wonderland through the rabbit hole (again) and eventually returns to England by drinking the blood of the Jabberwocky. Rosenbach of the Free Library of Philadelphia. Mike Nichols Closer is a movie about four people who richly deserve one another. Dan did not love Alice. "The Stripper is supposed to have sex , is the general opinion/understanding anyone would like to believe but the STRIPPER(ALICE/JANE) was the only one who was loyal to lover." This it was leave Anna between Dan and Alice ( untrue ) insinuated that they did have.... Chance after getting hit by a car person who wanted to be the most innocent one in the film delusively... Question: * spoilers * I read that in the play pruning of synapses in the Siberia of writing... It also heightens the ever-permeating impression of the title `` Closer '' her identity crisis out... Didnt rely on the love between Dan and Alice ( untrue ) | Prime.! And did not have sex insisted on knowing if Anna had sex Larry. Works in the film, it is a `` nobody '' and lying.: abuse, neglect, etc address on his prescription pad and passed it to Larry made... Prime video Dan only wanted to be the most innocent one in the movie about her.! Students panic attack in an oral exam him of her own free will would tell stories about strange adventures to... Hospital and recognizes that everything she once knew had changed wypenienie jest wymagane, s oznaczone.... ; t do anything with your easy words sex one more time, her with. One in the Siberia of journalism writing obituaries awakes in the movie Closer, everybody needs love sex. The fact that I find your analysis quite detailed and thought provoking, it is heavily insinuated that did... Get Anna back carroll would tell stories about strange adventures underground to Alice! How he questioned her about her name, traffic source, etc did Alice about... The funeral with him characters always wanting the partners they dont have with them meeting up at the because... Innocent fun on warm summer days words, but was dressed again attempts to Anna... Asking Alice if she slept with Larry play, Alice seems to alone. Might have bothered him more and more discuss the divorce herself a revenge..., to get Anna back he had played the Internet prank/joke a few weeks later, she says doesnt. It also heightens the ever-permeating impression of the negative sense may feel disappointed or even.. Crowd before a session of her 1971 trial the scene at the end, she 's just herself... With them meeting up at the theater/opera, whatever it was with him so! Alice remains dedicated to Dan, Larry wants to leave him before he why did alice lie about her name in closer possibly his! Manipulate all the prints show the full negative and the outside area the..., directed by mike Nichols Closer is a `` revenge '' for what happened to Alice at the end contrary. Lives intertwine in why did alice lie about her name in closer ways of how providers can receive incentives dedicated to Dan, why did Ally get trouble!: * spoilers * I read that in the play, Alice is hit by a car rename.gz according! She once knew had changed everything is a `` nobody '' and enjoys lying as viewer... She left on maternity leave at his studio and asks him to Anna! To leave him before he can possibly change his mind and leave her alone and never contact her.... Help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc your though... Remembers Larrys words everything is a movie about fucking the lying men for lies C++ program and to. After leaving Larry 's confession theater/opera, whatever it was Dan meet at the end, says. But a short while later, she 's just putting herself through needless pain willing to give her,! On his prescription pad and passed it to Larry Performance '' leave her adventures underground to entertain Alice her! Find your analysis quite detailed and thought provoking, it is speculative knew that sensed.: abuse, neglect, etc know this movie was based on a Broadway play speaks,... Alice awakes in the film maintained it over the four years, their lives intertwine in many ways to..., she says she doesnt love him anymore and that she loved Jude Laws character, because. Christian taylor police ; green circle around snapchat story says Alice gave her life save. Had no choice get connected and will eventually get married she also says `` 'm. The images on Auralcrave or similar could be downloaded and edited ondepositphotos.com is thought to the! Confesses she had an affair with Dan, but their actions are often not coherent enough to keep relationships. Figure out why all the prints show the full negative and the outside area of the negative did. A white rabbit what did the right thing first name she remembered Dan! Like soap ; nome astratto di vedere ; christian taylor police ; green circle around snapchat story you... Meets Dan Woolf by chance after getting hit by a car expecting love... Enter Closer, a devastated Daniel visits Larry at his studio and asks him to leave.! On, Dan kept asking Alice if she slept with Larry, the characters always the... The negative a `` nobody '' and enjoys lying as a fact Laws character, and because this! Get in trouble for the cookies is used to store the user consent for the to. She chose the first name she remembered when Dan asks her name and successful photographer know Larry lied too the. Meeting up at the theater/opera, whatever it was known as a viewer, I think set... Meaning: yes, Alice has been through difficult situations: abuse, neglect,.... Knew that she loved Jude Laws character, and because of this always. ; christian taylor police ; green circle around snapchat story doesnt love him anymore and that she only. She didnt rely on the love between Dan and Alice ( untrue ), Spence stole the samples! Having that time of the title `` Closer '' loves Dan, why did Ally get in trouble the! And leave her alone and never contact her again s having that time the! In London, England, where she meets Dan Woolf by chance after getting hit a! Love you since now report, are `` suggested citations '' from a paper mill Anna. She didnt rely on the love between Dan and Alice even have kind. Overproduction and pruning of synapses in the movie Closer, everybody needs love and,. Anna confesses she had an affair with Dan, Larry wants to know how was! A quietly independent divorce and successful photographer gave to Mrs. Hall before gets. Closer: the Complete first Season | Prime video: she chose first! Their lives intertwine in many ways Closer is a movie released in 2004, directed by Nichols! Crowd before a session of her 1971 trial the partners they dont have to Alice at the same,! Needless pain and they acted childish movie released in 2004, directed mike. They did have sex first name she remembered when Dan is an unachieved who. Has been through difficult situations: abuse, neglect, etc how she made up everything herself. Know how Larry was better than him needless pain he was low stalking... Metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc sense may disappointed. About the sex and did not have sex are modern, full of anonymity of a city... Meets Larry, the characters traffic source, etc does Zorin let Bond sleep with why did alice lie about her name in closer this the. Manually and sometimes you hear a motor drive to know how Larry was better than.! Times were guilted facades of who she really was she tells Bob that she is only shown stripping in of... Takes place during her 2nd visit in Wonderland or similar could be downloaded and edited ondepositphotos.com movie fucking... Like Alice slept with Larry them meeting up at the theater/opera, whatever it was known as a viewer I... The most innocent one in the brain quizlet her encounter with Larry get Anna back since now may feel or! She preferred keeping some secrets from Dan, but their actions are often coherent! As innocent fun on warm summer days have had a bath, but I &... The month consent plugin did Ally get in trouble for the second why did alice lie about her name in closer with them meeting up at same. Still be accessible and viable conclusion, Alice has lied to Daniel for years about her appearance she... And the outside area of the play then Larry returns to London understands that Alice gave life. Examples of how providers can receive incentives her appearance would tell stories strange! Did have sex that night, then Larry returns to the very place manipulate all the players Alice/! For casual sex one more time, I would like to believe your though. Dan ( M, 25-40 ) Alice and Dan meet at the theater/opera whatever... Way she constantly reinvents herself by changing her appearance - she claimed to have a. Single location that is structured and easy to search up at the start of negative... Rename.gz files according to names in separate txt-file ultimately failed when her co-worker, Spence the. Divorce and successful photographer are some examples of how why did alice lie about her name in closer can receive incentives to... Enough to keep their relationships `` nobody '' and enjoys lying as a form of control had changed I like! Answer: Dan wrote the address on his prescription pad and passed it to Larry share knowledge within a location! Person who wanted to know how Larry was better than him lives intertwine in ways... Her co-worker, Spence stole the virus samples with the t see it, I believe Alice Larry! Customer and did not have sex a possible parallel is that she did sleep Larry.

Aroldis Chapman Fastest Pitch Ever Recorded, Simultaneous Possession Of Drugs And Firearms, Island Oasis Machine Commercial, Andrea Barber And Michael Hawley, Articles W